Housing Bubble, credit bubble, public planning, land use, zoning and transportation in the exurban environment. Specific criticism of smart growth, neotradtional, forms based, new urbanism and other top down planner schemes to increase urban extent and density. Ventura County, California specific examples.
Tuesday, February 13, 2007
Everybody talks about it but...
Today, the Ventura city council officially announced a novel program to embrace “New Weather Urbanism” as a model for Ventura. “For too long, we’ve allowed uncontrolled sprawling -casual- weather to dictate how we live. No more. From now on, we will be actively encouraging a more compact range oftemperatures for our city – ideally between 65 and 78 degrees Fahrenheit,” he said. “And the morning overcast? We’re definitely going to reign that in.”
Ventura’s current weather pattern of overcast, onshore flows, and inconvenient rainy seasons was described as “car-centric," automobile inducing and “anti-pedestrian”. “Our current weather has made the car’s combination of air conditioning, roof, and wipers far too compelling. It’s time to stop adapting to the weather, and make the weather adapt to what we want,” said the mayor, touting Ventura's unique approach of taking weathermen to task rather than developers. And that something is a bold as it is pervasive.
“Have you ever tried to walk a half-mile in a business suit to a light rail station when it’s 82 degrees and 60% humidity? You’d stay drier riding one of those water rides at Magic Mountain,” said one local commuter, who believes the new approach to weather should substantially improve walkability and street life in local neighborhoods.
One reason given for the program was a perceived need for more open space. As people run from air-conditioned house to air-conditioned car to air-conditioned office building, the feeling of constant enclosure is pervasive. “The Ventura region actually has plenty of open space, but now we’ll get to actually experinece it year-round,” said the mayor.
Heat-induced sweating was also identified as a major problem for the temporary tattoos of the hipster “creative class” that cities like Ventura so desperately wish to attract and retain. “It’s, like, totally uncool dude,” said twenty-something Dirk Duany as he wiped the sweat from his brow once again while baking in the heat of a quaint sidewalk café ( Ventura has tried to achieve the same ambience with “tunnel cafés” in the downtown high rise building sector, but they’ve never had quite the same panache as a Paris street café.)
In general, the new program is looking to increase the overall density ratio of good weather days vs. bad weather days. In establishing the new guidelines New York’s “bitter cold” urbanism was compared to Portland’s “constant drizzle” model and San Diego’s “always perfect” approach. After much heated debate, San Diego’s “always perfect” approach won out. The new weather will definitely take some getting used to. “Venturans have a very ingrained habit of keeping an eye on weather reports before committing to a pedestrian urban mode. San Diego’s unconcerned blasé attitude will take some time to develop,” said Deputy Mayor Carl E. Morehouse.
Ventura is the largest city in America trying to eliminate zoning, and they don’t plan to use traditional zoning in this program either. Instead, “form-based weather design guidelines” will be set, allowing for some flexibility. “Sunny, partly cloudy, overcast, even a gentle rain shower from time to time – all will be acceptable within the city limits – but extremes of heat, cold, and rain will not be tolerated,” said Anne Diagle, City Manager Rick Cole's special assistant for urban design.
Oxnard, Camarillo, Moorpark, and Thousand Oaks are all watching the innovative program very closely, hoping to adapt it to their cities if it succeeds in Ventura although Oxnard staffers off the record expressed concern that their city might become a "dumping ground" for substandard meterological events. "It raises the question of ethnic preference when suddenly one city like ours is expected to handle an increase in weather." This raises the spectre of a renewal of the Mall Wars of the 1990s when each community tried to capture the best of a retail explosion while pawning off the traffic on the other.
"I don't know why they didn't do this earlier. It seems so obvious in retrospect," said one citizen at the event, "You always hear people complain about the weather, but someone is finally actually doing something about it..."
Labels:
Planning
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
6 comments:
You know the drill.
Read post, drink coffee, replace keyboard.
Good one, Rob.
-jbjbj
Mac keyboards are sooo freakin' expensive. Time to set up that tip jar. ;-)
This was just a humorous sidebar as someone asked what kind of land use discussions occur in Ventura County and I am preparing a serious article describing the process here.
The coworkers can't figure out why I keep laughing to myself. Hilarious, Rob Dawg.
But you aren't laughing by yourself. Personally I wouldn't even put me in the top 10 of the funniest posters. Those Casey Channelers are way out there, Sputnik dropped by, Ogg is in full form and even if I didn't think so I'm too scared of getting a tire tread tattoo on my spine to not mention Stephanie J.
The post itself is funny because it really does expose the inanity of the nascent "forms based development" paterns being foisted upon a public that is still struggling to combat smart growth as the latest subterfuge. Ooops, hit my big wurds limit. Gotta go.
<:(
Uhhh ohhh. Now I'm in for it.
Post a Comment